Last Updated: February 28, 2025

Does Landlord Insurance Cover Eviction? A Guide for New and Aspiring Rental Property Investors

As a new or aspiring rental property investor focusing on 1-4 unit properties like single-family townhomes or row homes, understanding the nuances of landlord insurance is crucial to protecting your investment. One of the most challenging aspects of property management that investors face is the eviction process, which can be costly, time-consuming, and legally complex. This comprehensive guide addresses a common question among new landlords: does landlord insurance cover eviction?

Understanding Landlord Insurance Basics

Before diving into eviction coverage specifically, it's important to understand what landlord insurance is designed to protect. Landlord insurance, also known as rental property insurance, is specifically designed for property owners who rent out their residential properties to tenants. Unlike homeowners insurance, which is intended for owner-occupied residences, landlord insurance provides specialized coverage for the unique risks associated with rental properties.

A standard landlord insurance policy typically includes three core types of protection:

1. Property Coverage: Protects the physical structure of your rental property against covered perils such as fire, lightning, wind, hail, and certain types of water damage.
2. Liability Coverage: Protects you if someone is injured on your property and you're found legally responsible, covering legal fees and potential settlements.
3. Loss of Rental Income: Provides coverage for lost rental income if your property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss.

However, standard policies vary widely in terms of what they cover beyond these basics—and this is where eviction-related concerns come into play.

What Will Landlord Insurance Cover?

Standard Coverage Components

A typical landlord insurance policy for townhomes or row homes will generally cover:

• Dwelling Protection: Covers the structure itself, including walls, roof, foundation, and built-in appliances from covered perils.
• Other Structures: Covers detached structures on the property such as sheds, detached garages, or fences.
• Personal Property Used for Property Maintenance: Covers items you own that are used to service the rental, such as lawn mowers or snow blowers (but not tenant belongings).
• General Liability Protection: Covers legal fees and medical expenses if a tenant or visitor is injured on your property and you're found legally responsible.
• Loss of Rental Income: Also called "fair rental value," this reimburses you for lost rental income if your property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss.

Eviction-Specific Coverage

Now, to address the primary question: Does landlord insurance cover eviction costs?

The short answer is: Most standard landlord insurance policies do not directly cover eviction costs. However, some premium policies or additional endorsements/riders may offer limited coverage for certain eviction-related expenses.

The costs associated with eviction typically include:

1. Court filing fees
2. Attorney fees
3. Process server fees
4. Sheriff's deputy fees (for physical eviction)
5. Property damage remediation after eviction
6. Lost rental income during the eviction process

Standard landlord policies generally do not cover these expenses because evictions are considered a business risk rather than an insurable peril. Evictions often result from tenant non-payment or lease violations, which are seen as normal business operations risks rather than sudden, accidental occurrences that insurance typically covers.

Landlord Legal Costs Coverage

While standard policies don't typically cover eviction costs, some insurance companies offer optional legal expense coverage that can help with eviction-related legal fees. Here's what you should know about legal protection coverage:

Types of Legal Coverage Available

1. Legal Expense Coverage Endorsement: This optional add-on can help cover attorney fees and court costs associated with tenant disputes, including evictions. The coverage limit is typically between $5,000 and $10,000.
2. Rent Guarantee Insurance: Though less common in the U.S. market (more prevalent in the UK and Australia), this coverage specifically protects against non-payment of rent and may include some eviction costs.
3. Tenant Default Insurance: Similar to rent guarantee insurance, this covers lost rental income due to tenant default and sometimes includes legal costs for eviction.

What Legal Coverage Typically Includes

If you opt for legal expense coverage, it might help with:

• Attorney consultation fees
• Court filing fees
• Representation costs in eviction hearings
• Legal document preparation
• Mediation costs

Coverage Limitations and Exclusions

Even with legal expense coverage, be aware of these common limitations:

• Coverage Caps: Most policies limit legal expense coverage to a specific dollar amount (often $5,000-$10,000).
• Waiting Periods: Many policies implement a waiting period before eviction coverage becomes effective (typically 30-90 days after policy inception).
• Pre-Existing Conditions: Issues with tenants that began before policy purchase are typically excluded.
• Tenant Screening Requirements: Some policies require proof that you conducted proper tenant screening before renting to the problematic tenant.

Example Scenario

Let's illustrate with a common scenario:

You own a townhome in Philadelphia that you rent out for $1,800 per month. Your tenant stops paying rent and refuses to vacate. You file for eviction, which costs $300 in filing fees. You hire an attorney who charges $2,000 to handle the case. The eviction process takes three months, during which you receive no rent ($5,400 lost). After eviction, you discover $1,500 in damage beyond the security deposit.

With standard landlord insurance: You would likely receive no coverage for any of these costs.

With legal expense coverage: Your policy might cover the $300 filing fee and some or all of the $2,000 in attorney fees, up to your coverage limit. The lost rent and property damage would still typically not be covered under the legal expense portion.

What Will Not Be Covered

Understanding what landlord insurance doesn't cover is just as important as knowing what it does cover. Here are the common exclusions related to evictions and tenant issues:

Common Exclusions Related to Evictions

1. Non-payment of Rent: Standard policies don't cover lost income due to tenant non-payment (though rent guarantee insurance might).
2. Normal Eviction Costs: Court costs, filing fees, and attorney fees for standard evictions are typically not covered without special endorsements.
3. Tenant Abandonment: Costs associated with tenants who abandon the property are generally not covered.
4. Tenant Damage: While malicious damage by tenants might be covered under some policies, normal wear and tear or damage due to tenant negligence is typically excluded.
5. Tenant Relocation Costs: If you need to relocate tenants during repairs, these costs are generally not covered.
6. Cash for Keys Arrangements: Money paid to encourage problematic tenants to leave voluntarily is not covered.

Other Notable Exclusions in Landlord Policies

Beyond eviction-specific concerns, standard landlord insurance policies typically don't cover:

1. Tenant's Personal Property: Your tenants need their own renters insurance for their belongings.
2. Shared Property in Multi-unit Buildings: Common areas in multi-unit buildings may require separate coverage.
3. Equipment Breakdown: Standard policies don't typically cover the mechanical failure of systems like HVAC without specific endorsements.
4. Flood Damage: Flood insurance must be purchased separately through the National Flood Insurance Program or private insurers.
5. Pest Infestations: Damage from termites, bed bugs, or other pests is generally excluded.
6. Vacancy-Related Issues: Properties vacant for more than 30-60 days may have limited or no coverage without a vacancy permit or endorsement.

How Much Will It Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance with legal protection varies based on numerous factors, but understanding the general pricing structure can help you budget appropriately.

Average Costs of Landlord Insurance

For standard landlord insurance without special legal coverage, typical annual premiums for townhomes or row homes range from $900 to $1,800, approximately 15-30% higher than homeowners insurance for the same property. This range can vary significantly based on:

• Property Location: Properties in high-crime areas or regions prone to natural disasters cost more to insure.
• Property Value and Replacement Cost: Higher-value properties have higher premiums.
• Property Age and Condition: Older properties or those in poor condition typically cost more to insure.
• Coverage Limits: Higher coverage limits result in higher premiums.
• Deductible Amount: Higher deductibles lower premiums but increase out-of-pocket costs when filing claims.

Additional Costs for Legal Protection Coverage

Adding legal protection coverage that might help with eviction costs typically adds between $150 and $500 annually to your premium, depending on:

• Coverage Limits: Higher limits for legal expenses cost more.
• Insurance Provider: Some companies charge more for this coverage than others.
• Property Location: Legal costs vary by jurisdiction, affecting premium costs.
• Claims History: Prior legal claims may increase your premium.

Cost-Benefit Analysis

When deciding whether to pay for additional legal protection coverage, consider:

• Local Eviction Costs: Research typical attorney fees and court costs in your area.
• Local Eviction Laws: Some jurisdictions have tenant-friendly laws that make evictions more complex and costly.
• Your Risk Tolerance: Consider your financial ability to handle unexpected legal costs.
• Your Tenant Screening Process: Thorough screening reduces eviction risk but doesn't eliminate it.

For a typical townhome investor, legal expense coverage often provides good value, especially for first-time landlords who may not have experienced the eviction process before.

---

Landlord Insurance VS Homeowners Insurance

Many new investors make the critical mistake of maintaining a homeowners policy on their rental properties. This can lead to denied claims and potential financial disaster.

Key Differences

1. Occupancy Assumption: Homeowners insurance assumes the owner lives in the property, while landlord insurance is designed for non-owner-occupied properties.
2. Liability Coverage Focus: Homeowners liability covers personal liability, while landlord liability specifically covers rental business liabilities.
3. Loss of Use vs. Loss of Income: Homeowners policies cover additional living expenses if you can't live in your home; landlord policies cover lost rental income.
4. Personal Property Coverage: Homeowners insurance covers your personal belongings throughout the property; landlord insurance only covers property used for maintenance.
5. Pricing: Landlord insurance typically costs 15-30% more than comparable homeowners coverage.

Coverage Comparison Table

Why Using Homeowners Insurance for Rental Properties Is Risky

If you maintain homeowners insurance on your rental property:

1. The insurer may deny claims once they discover the property is rented.
2. In worst-case scenarios, the company might retroactively rescind coverage.
3. You lack critical coverages specific to landlord risks.
4. You're personally exposed to tenant-related liability claims.

Always convert to a proper landlord policy when transitioning a property from owner-occupied to a rental.

Money-Saving Tips to Reduce Your Rental Property Insurance Costs

While adequate insurance protection is essential, there are legitimate ways to reduce your premium costs without sacrificing coverage.

Immediate Savings Opportunities

1. Bundle Policies: Combine your landlord insurance with other policies (auto, primary residence) for multi-policy discounts of 5-15%.
2. Increase Deductibles: Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 or $2,500 can reduce premiums by 10-25%. Just ensure you have the cash reserves to cover the higher deductible.
3. Pay Annually: Many insurers offer discounts of 5-10% for paying the full annual premium upfront rather than monthly.
4. Shop Around: Insurance markets vary significantly. Get quotes from at least 3-5 insurers, including both national companies and local/regional providers.
5. Ask About Discounts: Many companies offer discounts for:
   • New property owners
   • Recently renovated properties
   • Claims-free history
   • Professional property management
   • Security features
   • Fire protection systems

Long-Term Cost Reduction Strategies

1. Improve Property Security: Installing security systems, smart locks, exterior lighting, and fire prevention systems can qualify you for discounts while reducing claim likelihood.
2. Maintain and Update Property Systems: Regular maintenance and updates to electrical, plumbing, and HVAC systems reduce risk and may qualify for premium reductions.
3. Tenant Screening Investment: While not a direct insurance discount, thorough tenant screening reduces the likelihood of problem tenants, evictions, and claims.
4. Require Renters Insurance: Making renters insurance mandatory for tenants can sometimes reduce your landlord insurance costs, as it reduces the likelihood of tenants making claims against your policy.
5. Review Coverage Annually: As property values and replacement costs change, regularly review your coverage to ensure you're not over-insured.

Avoiding False Economies

While saving money is important, be careful not to:

1. Under-insure Your Property: Make sure your dwelling coverage reflects current rebuilding costs, not market value or purchase price.
2. Cut Liability Coverage: The difference between $300,000 and $1,000,000 in liability coverage is often minimal in premium but massive in protection.
3. Skip Optional Coverages Completely: Evaluate each optional coverage based on your specific risk profile rather than declining all to save money.

DSCR Requirements and Financing Through DSCR Loans

For investors using Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) loans to finance their townhome investments, insurance considerations become even more important as they can affect loan compliance.

Understanding DSCR Loans

DSCR loans are popular among real estate investors because they:

1. Qualify Based on Property Income: Rather than borrower income, these loans qualify based on the property's ability to generate sufficient rental income compared to expenses.
2. Provide Financing Options for Multiple Properties: Investors can scale their portfolios without bumping into conventional loan limits.
3. Offer Flexibility: These loans often have less stringent personal income verification requirements.

The DSCR is calculated by dividing the property's net operating income by its total debt service (mortgage payment). Lenders typically require a minimum DSCR of 1.25, meaning the property generates 25% more income than needed for the mortgage payment.

Insurance Requirements for DSCR Loans

DSCR lenders typically have strict insurance requirements, including:

1. Minimum Coverage Levels: Lenders usually require replacement cost coverage at 100% of the property's rebuild value.
2. Higher Liability Limits: Many DSCR lenders require $1,000,000 or more in liability coverage.
3. Loss of Rents Coverage: This is often mandatory and must cover at least 6-12 months of lost rental income.
4. Named Insured Requirements: The lender must be listed as an additional insured and mortgage clause holder.
5. Flood Insurance: Required for properties in designated flood zones, regardless of whether other properties in the area typically carry it.

How Insurance Costs Affect DSCR Calculations

Insurance premiums directly impact your DSCR calculation because they're included in your operating expenses. Higher insurance costs reduce your net operating income, potentially lowering your DSCR below lender requirements.

For example:

• Property with $24,000 annual rental income
• $15,000 annual mortgage payment
• $3,000 in property taxes
• $2,000 in insurance costs (without legal protection)
• DSCR = ($24,000 - $3,000 - $2,000) / $15,000 = 1.27

If adding legal protection coverage increases insurance by $400:

• DSCR = ($24,000 - $3,000 - $2,400) / $15,000 = 1.24

This seemingly small change could drop you below a lender's minimum requirement.

Balancing Insurance Protection with DSCR Requirements

To maintain adequate insurance protection while meeting DSCR requirements:

1. Shop for Value: Compare insurers based on coverage-to-premium ratio, not just the lowest price.
2. Consider Higher Deductibles: Higher deductibles can significantly lower premiums with minimal impact on protection.
3. Bundle When Possible: Multi-policy discounts can help offset the cost of additional coverages.
4. Increase Rent Strategically: When market conditions allow, modest rent increases can improve your DSCR while covering increased insurance costs.
5. Make Property Improvements: Insurance discounts for security and safety features can help offset the cost of enhanced coverage.

Building a Comprehensive Risk Management Strategy

While insurance is a crucial component of your risk management strategy as a townhome investor, it works best as part of a comprehensive approach:

1. Risk Prevention

• Thorough Tenant Screening: Verify income, employment, credit, criminal background, and rental history.
• Clear Lease Agreements: Ensure your lease clearly outlines all tenant obligations and consequences for violations.
• Regular Inspections: Conduct regular property inspections (with proper notice) to identify issues before they escalate.
• Preventive Maintenance: Address small issues before they become costly problems.
• Professional Property Management: Consider professional management for consistent policy enforcement.

2. Legal Preparedness

• Local Eviction Knowledge: Familiarize yourself with the specific eviction procedures in your property's jurisdiction.
• Attorney Relationship: Establish a relationship with a landlord-tenant attorney before you need one.
• Documentation System: Maintain meticulous records of all tenant communications, payments, and property conditions.
• Eviction Fund: Set aside funds specifically for potential eviction costs, regardless of insurance coverage.

3. Financial Buffers

• Emergency Reserves: Maintain reserves of at least 6 months of expenses per property.
• Vacancy Fund: Budget for potential vacancy periods separate from your emergency reserves.
• Insurance Deductible Fund: Have liquid funds available to cover your insurance deductibles.

4. Insurance Optimization

• Annual Coverage Review: Review your policy annually and after significant property changes.
• Coverage Coordination: Ensure your various insurance policies work together without gaps or redundancies.
• Claims Strategy: Understand when it makes financial sense to file a claim and when to handle expenses out-of-pocket.

Final Thoughts

For new and aspiring townhome investors, understanding landlord insurance coverage—especially regarding evictions—is crucial to protecting your investment. While standard landlord insurance typically doesn't cover eviction costs directly, optional legal expense coverage can provide valuable protection against some eviction-related expenses.

Remember these key points:

1. Standard landlord policies don't cover most eviction expenses without special endorsements.
2. Legal expense coverage can help with court costs and attorney fees but has limitations.
3. The best protection is prevention through thorough tenant screening and clear lease agreements.
4. Proper insurance is required for DSCR loans, and insurance costs directly impact your DSCR calculation.
5. Insurance is just one component of a comprehensive risk management strategy.

As you build your townhome investment portfolio, work closely with both an insurance professional who specializes in rental properties and a real estate attorney familiar with landlord-tenant law in your jurisdiction. This professional team can help you develop a customized strategy that protects your investment while controlling costs.

By taking a proactive approach to risk management, including appropriate insurance coverage, you'll be better positioned to weather the inevitable challenges of property management and build a successful, profitable rental property business.

---

Grow and optimize your rental property portfolio with OfferMarket

OfferMarket is a rental property investing platform. Membership is entirely free and includes access to the following:

🏠 Off market properties
💰 Private lending
☂️ Landlord insurance rate shopping
💡 Community & insights

Our mission is to help you build wealth through real estate. If you are not already a member, we hope you will accept our invitation to join us!

---